It’s been a month since I arrived in Turkey. Time flies.
This is probably the quietest weekend that I’ve ever had here so far: sitting in the couch, drinking a cup of Turkish chai, on Sunday afternoon. Looking out of the window of my apartment in downtown Ankara, guess how many Turkish flags can I see? Nine. That was my first impression of Turkey – flags everywhere. And of course, pictures of Ataturk everywhere. Turks love their country, I think.
View from my balcony. Sorry that it's not big enough to see the Turkish flags.
I was amazed when I first arrived and saw so many Turkish flags. Apart from the flag poles either standing in squares or on top of buildings, small flags can be found in offices, restaurants, buses, cars or hanging from apartment buildings. Maybe it’s because this is the capital, I thought.
Being in the capital city of Turkey, as a Chinese, I can’t help recalling my memories of Beijing, the capital city of China. I visited Beijing 10 years ago for the first time, but I couldn’t remember that much because I was too young. I’ve always been longing to visit it again, and now I have fresh memories of it because I travelled there this January, just before I left Shanghai for Ankara.
Well, in Beijing, according to my memory, there were not as many flags as in Ankara. I had this kind of feeling because I paid attention when I am a foreign tourist and I don’t pay attention when I am a citizen? Hum, this may be part of the reason. Or maybe Beijing actually used to be like this in the first few years after People’s Republic of China was founded? But I think Turkish people and Chinese people are similar but just have different ways to show their love for country, in terms of national flags.
Instead of putting flags everywhere, we have the most significant flag-raising ceremony at Tiananmen Square everyday at dawn, which every tourist to Beijing knows. For foreigners, even for some Chinese, watching this flag-raising ceremony can be a once-in-lifetime opportunity. I attended the ceremony once when I visited Beijing the second time. I think you cannot be called a real Chinese if you haven’t been to. I felt so proud to be a Chinese when I saw the flag raised as the national anthem plays.
Chinese Flag being raised at Tianmanmen Square. (I took this picture when I was at the ceremony)
When two countries are compared with each other, Hofsted’s five cultural dimensions is one of the mostly used methods. I learned about it in both “Introduction to Communication Studies” class, “Intercultural Communication” class and “Advanced Issues in Communication Studies” class, either in Hong Kong or Turkey.
Geert Hofsted has found five dimensions of culture, which is of great use when analyzing and comparing people in different countries, especially during cross-cultural communications. The five dimensions are:
1. Small vs. large power distance: the extent to which the less powerful members of organizations and institutions accept and expect that power is distributed unequally.
2. Individualism vs. collectivism: the degree to which individuals are integrated into groups.
3. Masculinity vs. femininity: the measurement of the value placed on traditionally male or female values.
4. Strong vs. weak uncertainty avoidance: a society’s tolerance for uncertainty and ambiguity.
5. Long-term vs. short-term orientation: the importance attached to the future versus the past and present.
Let’s see the index of China and Turkey based on research.
| Power distance | Individualism | Masculinity | Uncertainty avoidance | Long-term orientation |
China | 80 | 20 | 66 | 40 | 118 |
Turkey | 66 | 37 | 45 | 85 | |
Both Chinese and Turkish people rank high in power distance index, which means the less powerful accept power relations that are autocratic or paternalistic. I think this has a lot to do with the history of both countries. See what I found about the word “imperialism”: Imperialism in ancient times is clear in the unending succession of empires in China, western Asia, and the Mediterranean; Imperialism is most commonly related to historical content such as the ancient histories of Rome, Greece, and China. Yes, that’s exactly what I thought when I was visiting the Topkaki Palace in Istanbul. As I said in my last post, I found so many similar elements between the palace of Sultans and palace of Chinese emperors.
Both Chinese and Turkish people rank low in individualism. I think this also has something to do with the imperialism in ancient times, and in China I think the spread of Confucius has been playing an important role, as Confucian beliefs emphasize on collectivistic values.
The biggest difference between Chinese and Turkish people comes to uncertainty avoidance. Well, according to the figure, Turkish people tend to adopt strict rules, laws, policies, and regulations. I talked to one of my professors who is a specialist in Turkey studies, and he said that this is highly related to Islamic culture. Hum, that’s probably right. You see, Muslims pray five times a day, on fixed schedules, which shows that they have explicit rule on religious. I did a little research about this, and it’s not strange to find that all Muslim countries, such as Arab World, rank high in Power Distance and Uncertainty Avoidance (http://www.geert-hofstede.com/hofstede_arab_world.shtml).
See the Turkish flag? The crescent moon is a traditional Islamic symbol. See the Chinese flag? A big star circled by four small ones stands for the Communist Party is centered by people of all ethnic groups of the country. Isn’t that an interesting example of Chinese collectivism? Well, I think religion has a huge influence on a country’s culture.
Oh yeah, some of us exchange students are planning to go to a Hamam (Turkish bath) some day. It can be an interesting experience I guess, and maybe it can be a good opportunity to see real Turkish people’s life. But an exchange student from France said that none of his roommates (local Turkish students) have ever been to a Hamam.
Well, it’s kind of interesting that you may doubt whether they are real Turks or not, but I think this is understandable because usually local people wouldn’t do what tourists do, just like a lot of Paris citizens haven’t been up to the Eiffel Tower; a lot of New York citizens haven’t been up to the Statue of Liberty; a lot of Beijing citizens haven’t been to Tiananmen Square to watch the flag-raising ceremony… just because people are so close to it that they ignore the importance of it.
We plan to visit somewhere else next weekend. Alright, local Turkish people, any suggestions? You must have some ideas. If you haven’t been to the place we’re going to, maybe you can join us :)